From: Devices used for photobiomodulation of the brain—a comprehensive and systematic review
Device (company) | No. of reports | Category | Description | Location | Actuation area (cm2) | Wavelength (nm)a | Mode of operation | Power density (mW/cm2) | Energy density (J/cm2) | Energy per session (J) | Power output (W) | Study |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bloodcare Medical Laser Device (Shanghai Taicheng Technology&Development Co. Ltd., CN) [32] | 1 | Intranasal laser | GaInP/AlGaInP diode | Intranasal | 0.358 | 650 | NR | 8.38 | NR | NR | NR | Blood conditions |
Intranasal laser without name information [37] | 1 | Intranasal laser | Optical fibre-based frontal light diffuser | Intranasal | 0.0057 | 671 or 808 | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0.8; 1 | Light penetration |
3 | Intranasal LED | 1 LED diode | Ventromedial prefrontal, entorhinal cortex, hippocampus | 1 | 810 | 10 Hz 50% DC | 14.20 | 10.65 | 10.65 | 0.014 | AD; Dementia; Gulf War Illness | |
Intranasal LED without name information [33] | 1 | Intranasal LED | NR | Brainstem | NR | 660 | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR | PD |
Vielight Intranasal 633 (Vielight Inc., CA) [14] | 1 | Intranasal LED | 1 LED diode | Ventromedial prefrontal, entorhinal cortex, hippocampus | 1 | 633 | Continuous | 8 | 12 | 12 | 0.0080 | Gulf War illness |
4 | Laser | NR | PFC bilaterally; left motor cortex; several regions; | 0.0314–35.8 | 808, 820, 830, 852 or 1064 | Continuous; 10 Hz and 100 Hz 20% DC | 54.8; 167; 310 | Mostly NR; 65.8 | 1635; 2300 | 2; 2.3; 5 | Physiological characterisation; cognitive function; depression; light penetration | |
Model CG-5000 Laser (Cell Gen Therapeutics LLC, US) [9, 11, 12, 20, 29, 41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53,54] | 19 | Laser handpiece | Laser with collimated beam, connected to fibre optic cable | Right PFC; dorsolateral PFC bilaterally | 12.56–13.85 per site | 1064 | Continuous | 162–257.40 | 60–137.5 | 1496–1680 | 2.20–3.50 | Cognitive function; physiological characterisation; depression; fear |
NeuroThera® Laser System (Photothera, Inc., US) [22, 55,56,57] | 4 | Laser handpiece | Class IV laser | Frontal, parietal, temporal, and occipital regions; PFC bilaterally | 7.1 per site | 808 | Mostly NR; continuous | Mostly NR, 700 | NR, 1 or 84 | Mostly NR; 2400 | Mostly NR; 5 | Stroke; depression |
2 | Laser handpiece | Collimated laser | Left and right PFC | 13.6 per site | 1064 | Continuous | 250 | 120 or 150 | 1632b | 3.40 | Bipolar; physiological characterisation | |
2 | Laser handpiece | Class IV laser probe | PFC and temporal regions bilaterally | NR | 810 | Continuous and 10 Hz | NR | 55 to 81 | NR | 10–15 | TBI; TBI with depression | |
2 | Laser handpiece | Laser with collimated beam, connected to fibre optic cable | Calvaria, bregma | 1.075 per site | 800 and 970 or 800 | NR | 200–700 | NR | NR | NR | Light penetration | |
2 | Laser handpiece | 21 laser diodes | Superior edge of fossa sphenoidale, upper edge of the two fossa sphenoidalis | NR | 785 | Continuous | 10 | 1 | 126 | NR | Severe disorder of consciousness; TBI | |
Theralase® TLC-2000 CLT (Theralase Technologies Inc., CA) [63, 64] | 2 | Laser handpiece | 5 near-infrared (NIR) laser diodes and 4 RED laser diodes | Midline occipital region, Circle of Willis, and over the mastoid processes bilaterally; PFC various locations | NR | 660 and 905 or 905 | Superpulsed (200 ns) | NR | NR | 315 | 0.05 or 0.13 | ADHD; TBI |
2 | Laser handpiece | 4 laser diodes | back of neck; several regions, basal ganglia and susbtantia nigra (intraoral) | 0.196 or 0.635 | 904 | 50 Hz | 47 | NR | 10 or 39.6 | 0.12 or 0.3 | PD | |
2 | Laser handpiece | 1 diode laser connected through an optic fibre to a laser driver | Right PFC | 0.785 | 808 | NR | 318 | NR | 150 | 0.25 | Physiological characterisation | |
Aspen Pinnacle diode (Aspen Laser LLC, US) [67] | 1 | Laser handpiece | Commercial model | Temporal lobe, PFC, left hippocampus | 7.065 per site | 810 | 10 Hz | 177–354 | 5–60 | 110–4000 per location | 5–25 | AD |
CTL-1100 low power laser (Toptica, DE) [68] | 1 | Laser handpiece | Commercial model | Cervical | 1 per site | 810–830 | 6 kHz | NR | 4 | NR | 0.10 | Vertebrobasilar insufficiency |
Endolaser 476 (Enraf Nonius, NL) [69] | 1 | Laser handpiece | GaAs laser probe | Primary motor cortex | 1 per site | 905 | 3 kHz | 50 | 15 | NR | NR | Physiological characterisation |
Laser Lumix 3 Plus Ultra model (Fisioline S.r.l., IT) [70] | 1 | Laser handpiece | Commercial model | Primary motor cortex bilaterally | 3.14 per site | 808 | Continuous | 200 | 60 | NR | NR | Motor performance |
LiteCure® LT1000 (LiteCure LLC, US) [59] | 1 | Laser handpiece | Class IV laser probe | PFC and temporal regions bilaterally | NR | 810 and 980 | Continuous and 10 Hz | NR | 55 to 81 | NR | 10–13 | TBI with depression |
Laser helmet without name information [71] | 1 | Laser helmet | 12 RED and 12 IR LEDs arranged on a helmet | Whole head | NR | 630 and 810 | 75 Hz 20% DC | 800 | 144 | NR | 2.4 | Schizophrenia |
Laser WeberMedical Klasse 1, Type BF, Laser Class 3B (Weber medical GmbH, DE) [72] | 1 | Laser needles | Collimated laser beam connected to fibre optic cable and four stainless steel laser diode needles | Primary motor cortex | 0.35 | 810 | Continuous | 500 | NR | NR | 0.15 | Physiological characterisation |
8 | LED | NR | PFC; dorsolateral PFC bilaterally; midbrain (back of neck); whole head without PFC; frontal sinus; frontal and parietal lobes | 1.32–80, mostly NR | 627, 810, 940 or 945 | Mostly NR; continuous; 5–20 Hz 50% DC | 6–250 | 9.35–65.7 | NR | Mostly NR, 0.11, 0.20 | Drug abuse; anxiety and depression; physiological characterisation; PD | |
MedX Health Model 1100 (MedX Health Services Inc., CA) [14, 17, 18, 30, 81] | 6 | LED cluster | One, two or three LED clusters. 49 or 61 diodes (9 RED + 40 or 52 NIR diodes) | PFC various locations; frontal, occipital, parietal, and temporal regions; ears | 19.39 or 22.48 per cluster | 633 and 870 or 870 | Continuous or 146 Hz | 4–44.40 | 1–39 | 42.30–1349 | 0.09, 0.5 or 1 per cluster | TBI; cognitive function; Gulf War illness; stroke |
4 | LED cluster | Two similar clusters used simultaneously, except for light penetration | Dorsolateral PFC bilaterally; frontal, left, and right parietal skull and frontal, temporal, and occipital skull | 28.7 per cluster | 633, 823, 830 or 633 and 830 | Continuous | 33.2–72.6 | 40–65.2 | Mostly NR; 3440 | Mostly NR; 1 per cluster | Autism; depression; sexual dysfunction; light penetration | |
3 | LED cluster | 20 diodes—square | Right PFC | 1.4 | 850 | Continuous | 285 | 42.75 or 60 | 60c | 0.4 | Cognitive function; physiological characterisation | |
3 | LED cluster | 9 or 5 diodes | PFC various locations | 5d | 810 | Continuous | 20 | 7 | NR | NR | Cognitive function; dementia | |
2 | LED cluster | 4 LED clusters | PFC bilaterally; dorsolateral PFC bilaterally | 35.8 | 830 | Continuous (c) or pulsed (p) 10 Hz 33% DC | 54.80 | c—65.80 or p—21.70 | c—2300 or p—800 | c—2 or p—0.70 | AD; physiological characterisation | |
L-light (SUN-MECHATRONICS, JP) [91] | 1 | LED cluster | 23 diodes—square | PFC bilaterally | 21.85 per cluster | 850 | Continuous | 11.40 | 20.5 | 538 | 0.299 | Physiological characterisation |
Cerebral Science (Center for Anxiety and Traumatic Stress Disorders, US) [92] | 1 | LED headband | NR | PFC various locations | 80 | 830 | Continuous | 30 | 36 | 2900 | 2.4 | Anxiety |
OEG-SpO2 (Spectratech Inc., JP) [93] | 1 | LED headband | Six light emitters and six light detectors | Central PFC | NR | 770 and 840 | 12.21 Hz | 25 | NR | NR | NR | Cognitive function/function |
4 | LED helmet | 18/12/13 clusters of 20/70 or 14/4 LEDs | Whole head (two with ocular stimulation) | 400; ~ 650 | 630, 810 or 1060–1080 | Mostly NR; continuous | 23.1; 36 | 3.74; 43 | Mostly NR; 1494 | 10.79; 15 | AD; dementia; TBI | |
Cognitolite Transcranial Photomodulation System (Cognitolite LLC, US) [96, 97] | 2 | LED helmet | 14 or 15 arrays of 70 LEDS—air cooled | Whole head (with eyes) | NR | 1060–1080 | 10 Hz 50% DC | 12 per module | NR | 1368 | 3.80 | Cognitive function/function; AD |
Duo Coronet (Wellred, AU) [33] | 1 | LED helmet | Aluminium sheets lined with LED strips. 670 and 810-nm (n = 150), 850-nm (n = 120) | Whole head | NR | 670, 810 and 850 | Continuous | NR | NR | NR | 39.36e | PD |
InLight Wellness Systems (Inlight Therapy Inc., US) [15] | 1 | LED helmet | 2 neoprene pads with 180 RED and 222 NIR LEDs. One pad circled the skull, the other covered the top of the head | Whole head | 519 | 629 and 850 | 73, 587, and 1175 Hz 35% DC | 6.40 | 7.7 | 3994 | 3.3 | TBI |
LumiWave (BioCare Systems, Inc., US) [98] | 1 | LED helmet | 784 NIR GaAIAs LEDs in a cap configuration: four linear pod sets each with 4 LED clusters with 49 LEDs | Occipital, temporal, frontal and parietal regions | 360 | 903 | NR | 16.67 | 20 | NR | NR | TBI |
Photobiomodulation Helmet (Suyzeko, CN) [13] | 1 | LED helmet | 256 diodes | Whole head | NR | 810 | NR | 24 | NR | NR | ~ 15 | Physiological characterisation |
PhotoMedex LED lined helmet (Photomedex INC., US) [14] | 1 | LED helmet | 18 LED clusters (4.5 × 4.8 cm)—20 diodes per cluster | Whole head | 388.8 | 830 | Continuous | 29 | 26 | 19,043 | ~ 11.30 | Gulf War illness |
Thor photomedicine LED lined helmet (THOR Photomedicine Ltd, UK) [14] | 1 | LED helmet | 5 or 10 LED clustersf—69 diodes per cluster. Midline clusters or right and left ear clusters | Whole head, ears | 141.5 or 283 | 660 and 850 | Continuous | 41 or 35 | 26 | 4063 or 8130 | 6.328 or 10.754 | Gulf War illness |
Transcranial helmet (ProNeuroLIGHT LLC, US) [25] | 1 | LED helmet | Helmet—150 NIR LEDs and 50 RED LEDs | Whole head | NIR—18, RED—6 | 635 and 810 | Continuous | NIR—31, RED—75 | NIR—46.5, RED—112.5 | NIR—837, RED—675 | NIR—0.558, RED—0.450 | AD |
Vielight® Neuro Alfa (Vielight Inc., CA) [26, 99,100,101,102,103] | 6 | Localized LED helmet (intranasal and transcranial) | 3 posterior transcranial, 1 anterior transcranial, and 1 intranasal LED. Aluminium strips frame | Ventromedial prefrontal, entorhinal cortex, hippocampus (intranasal), central PFC, top of frontal lobe, temporal lobe bilaterally | 1 per LED | 810 | 10 Hz or 10 Hz 50% DC | Posterior—100, anterior—75, intranasal—25; transcranial—41, intranasal—23 | Posterior—60, anterior—45, intranasal—15; transcranial—24.6, intranasal—13.8 | 240; 309 | Posterior—0.10, anterior—0.075, intranasal—0.025; transcranial—0.041, intranasal—0.023 | Autism; cognitive function; dementia; Gulf War illness; physiological characterisation; TBI |
Vielight® Neuro Gamma (Vielight Inc., CA) [23, 99, 103,104,105,106] | 6 | Localized LED helmet (Intranasal and transcranial) | 3 posterior transcranial, 1 anterior transcranial, and 1 intranasal LED. Aluminium strips frame | Ventromedial prefrontal, entorhinal cortex, hippocampus (intranasal), central PFC, top of frontal lobe, temporal lobe bilaterally | 1 per LED | 810 | 40 Hz or 40 Hz 50% DC | Posterior—100, anterior—75, intranasal—25 | Posterior—60, anterior—45, intranasal—15 | 180; 240 | Posterior—0.10, anterior—0.075, intranasal—0.025 | AD; autism; cognition/function; PD; TBI |