Skip to main content

Table 2 Calibration results with three HNM categories in both single-speed modes and inter-speed mode on each participant

From: Fused ultrasound and electromyography-driven neuromuscular model to improve plantarflexion moment prediction across walking speeds

Subject

HNMs

Single-speed modes

  

0.50 m/s

0.75 m/s

1.00 m/s

  

RMSE

\(R^{2}\)

RMSE

\(R^{2}\)

RMSE

\(R^{2}\)

Sub01

sEMG

12.16

0.954

11.28

0.956

12.75

0.954

US imaging

14.49

0.921

14.62

0.926

12.94

0.951

sEMG-US imaging

11.79

0.965

10.25

0.964

11.77

0.960

Sub02

sEMG

5.96

0.932

6.93

0.936

7.70

0.934

US imaging

5.91

0.932

6.44

0.943

7.07

0.945

sEMG-US imaging

4.94

0.953

5.10

0.964

6.91

0.947

Sub03

sEMG

9.86

0.924

8.38

0.964

11.28

0.949

US imaging

13.68

0.857

11.17

0.937

12.29

0.940

sEMG-US imaging

8.33

0.946

6.49

0.979

9.81

0.962

Sub04

sEMG

12.04

0.820

17.14

0.842

13.79

0.904

US imaging

16.60

0.661

20.49

0.771

16.38

0.865

sEMG-US imaging

11.64

0.834

16.89

0.847

13.48

0.908

Sub05

sEMG

8.70

0.903

9.43

0.904

9.01

0.921

US imaging

9.10

0.894

9.77

0.897

9.54

0.911

sEMG-US imaging

7.90

0.920

8.96

0.913

8.97

0.921

Sub06

sEMG

6.36

0.963

6.15

0.974

9.35

0.953

US imaging

7.08

0.954

12.42

0.897

18.34

0.823

sEMG-US imaging

5.53

0.972

6.02

0.976

9.28

0.954

Sub07

sEMG

5.76

0.923

6.75

0.921

6.84

0.949

US imaging

6.22

0.911

8.34

0.879

7.31

0.942

sEMG-US imaging

5.46

0.932

6.48

0.927

6.67

0.951

Sub08

sEMG

4.98

0.973

6.64

0.957

9.20

0.936

US imaging

4.97

0.973

6.97

0.953

8.34

0.946

sEMG-US imaging

4.61

0.977

6.35

0.961

8.24

0.948

Sub09

sEMG

7.37

0.926

8.65

0.919

7.76

0.941

US imaging

8.99

0.894

9.55

0.901

8.13

0.936

sEMG-US imaging

7.22

0.929

8.27

0.926

7.24

0.949

Sub10

sEMG

9.31

0.935

7.27

0.973

12.24

0.940

US imaging

13.85

0.856

11.97

0.927

12.56

0.937

sEMG-US imaging

8.25

0.949

5.78

0.983

9.72

0.962

Subject

HNMs

Single-speed modes

Inter-speed mode

  

1.25 m/s

1.50 m/s

All speeds

  

RMSE

\(R^{2}\)

RMSE

\(R^{2}\)

RMSE

\(R^{2}\)

Sub01

sEMG

13.40

0.955

14.59

0.953

14.42

0.936

US imaging

13.85

0.952

13.38

0.960

18.79

0.893

sEMG-US imaging

12.61

0.960

12.76

0.964

12.95

0.949

Sub02

sEMG

13.47

0.823

11.29

0.874

10.62

0.862

US imaging

16.86

0.724

13.76

0.816

12.28

0.818

sEMG-US imaging

13.41

0.822

8.79

0.922

10.01

0.877

Sub03

sEMG

11.55

0.950

12.07

0.946

13.53

0.924

US imaging

11.62

0.950

13.01

0.938

16.19

0.916

sEMG-US imaging

9.38

0.967

11.30

0.952

11.38

0.951

Sub04

sEMG

14.91

0.893

14.89

0.913

17.14

0.848

US imaging

17.26

0.857

15.13

0.911

23.52

0.723

sEMG-US imaging

14.87

0.894

14.86

0.914

17.12

0.849

Sub05

sEMG

6.79

0.963

8.15

0.954

10.60

0.892

US imaging

6.87

0.961

8.51

0.949

12.97

0.840

sEMG-US imaging

6.67

0.964

8.08

0.954

10.48

0.895

Sub06

sEMG

8.74

0.964

18.06

0.884

13.13

0.905

US imaging

13.54

0.915

15.99

0.908

17.32

0.832

sEMG-US imaging

8.37

0.967

13.91

0.931

11.76

0.922

Sub07

sEMG

7.66

0.941

10.59

0.898

9.46

0.890

US imaging

7.38

0.946

9.37

0.920

10.41

0.868

sEMG-US imaging

7.04

0.951

9.02

0.927

8.64

0.909

Sub08

sEMG

11.74

0.912

14.98

0.864

14.98

0.864

US imaging

10.82

0.925

14.27

0.877

14.27

0.877

sEMG-US imaging

10.44

0.931

13.76

0.886

13.76

0.886

Sub09

sEMG

7.55

0.925

8.02

0.954

10.58

0.929

US imaging

9.64

0.878

8.28

0.923

14.38

0.870

sEMG-US imaging

6.87

0.955

7.92

0.955

10.08

0.933

Sub10

sEMG

12.10

0.946

10.85

0.956

13.14

0.939

US imaging

12.89

0.939

11.86

0.948

17.26

0.906

sEMG-US imaging

10.19

0.962

10.08

0.962

12.37

0.960

  1. (RMSE unit: N\(\cdot\)m)