Skip to main content

Table 1 Overview of Smoothness metrics identified from the literature

From: Smoothness metrics for reaching performance after stroke. Part 1: which one to choose?

Metric (Abbreviation)

Units

Articles useda

Exclusions

Category

Earliest citation

Index of curvature (IC)

[]

1

E3

Trajectory

[33]

Standard deviation in 2D plane (SD_XY)

[]

1

E3

Trajectory

[72]

Number of sub-movements (NOS)

[]

1

 

Velocity

[37]

Speed metric (SM)

[]

15

 

Velocity

[14]

Normalized reaching speed (NRS)

[]

2

E4 (SM)

Velocity

[35]

Movement arrest period ratio (MAPR)

[]

3

 

Velocity

[34]

Tent Metric (TM)

[]

1

E2

Velocity

[14]

Velocity Arc Length (VAL)

[]

1

 

Velocity

[4]

Correlation Metric (CM)

[]

2

 

Velocity

[38]

Peaks Metric (Peaks)

[]

61

 

Acceleration

[39]

Number of Movement Units (NMU)

[]

3

E4a (Peaks)

Acceleration

[73]

Number of peaks normalized by movement duration (NPt)

[s−1]

1

E1

Acceleration

[40]

Number of peaks normalized by movement distance (NPd)

[m−1]

3

E1

Acceleration

[41]

Inverse number of peaks and valleys (IPV)

[]

1

 

Acceleration

[44]

Acceleration metric (AM)

[]

2

E1

Acceleration

[35]

Integrated absolute jerk (IAJ)

[ms−2]

2

E1

Jerk

[74]

Mean absolute jerk (MAJ)

[ms−3]

2

E1

Jerk

[33]

Mean absolute jerk normalized by peak speed (MAJPS)

[s−2]

7

E1

Jerk

[14]

Integrated squared jerk (ISJ)

[m2s−5]

1

E1

Jerk

[75]

Root mean squared jerk metric (RMSJ)

[ms−3]

1

E1

Jerk

[76]

Normalized integrated jerk (NIJ)

[ms−3 \(\sqrt{\mathrm{s}}\)]

1

E1

Jerk

[77]

Dimensionless squared jerk (DSJt)

[]

12

 

Jerk

[3]

Log dimensionless squared jerk (LDSJt)

[]

1

 

Jerk

[5]

Dimensionless squared jerk (DSJm)

[]

1

E4a (DSJt)

Jerk

[2]

Dimensionless squared jerk (DSJb)

[]

1

 

Jerk

[4]

Log dimensionless squared jerk (LDSJb)

[]

1

 

Jerk

[4]

Rotational jerk (RJ)

[]

1

E3

Jerk

[48]

Spectral metric (SPMR)

[]

1

 

Frequency

[49]

Spectral method (SPM)

[]

1

 

Frequency

[1]

Spectral arc length 2012 (SPAL)

[]

8

 

Frequency

[4]

Spectral arc length (SPARC)

[]

1

 

Frequency

[6]

Combined smoothness metric (CSM)

[− −]b

1

E1

Other

[78]

  1. aNumber of articles in the systematic review that used the metric. bUnits were not available. Exclusion criteria include E1: metric was not dimensionless; E2: metric not reproducible from the literature; E3: metric not based on velocity or its derivative; and E4: metric linearly related to another metric (shown in brackets) by (a) scaling or (b) addition of a constant