Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary of included studies (n=10)

From: Robot-assisted gait training (Lokomat) improves walking function and activity in people with spinal cord injury: a systematic review

Study

Design

Participants

Intervention

Outcome measures

Alcobendas-Maestro 2012

RCT

n = 80

Time since injury (months) = 3 - 6

ASIA scale = C, D

Level of injury = C2 to T12 (UMN)

Exp = RAGT 30 min x 5/wk x 6 wk

Con = OGT 60 min x 5/wk x 6 wk

Both = Usual PT

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Distance = 6-min walk test

• Functional level = WISCI II, FIM-L

• Leg strength = LEMS

• Spasticity = MAS

• Pain = VAS

• Timing: 0, 8 wk

Duffell 2015

RCT

n = 56

Time since injury (months) > 12

ASIA scale = C, D

Level of injury = above T10 (UMN)

Exp = RAGT 30~45 min x 3/wk x 4 wk

Con = no intervention

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Distance = 6-min walk test

• Balance = TUG

• Timing: 0, 1, 2, 4 wk

Esclarin-Ruz 2014

RCT

n = 88

Time since injury (months) < 6

ASIA scale = C, D

Level of injury = C2 to L3 (UMN+LMN)

Exp = RAGT 30 min x 5/wk x 8 wk

Con = OGT 30 min x 5/wk x 8 wk

Both = Usual PT 60 min x 5/wk x 8 wk

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Distance = 6-min walk test

• Functional level = WISCI II, FIM-L

• Leg strength = LEMS

• Timing: 0, 8 wk

Field-Fote 2011

RCT

n = 74

Time since injury (months) > 12

ASIA scale = C, D

Level of injury = At or above T10 (UMN)

Exp = RAGT 60 min x 5/wk x 12 wk

Con1 = BWS treadmill-based training with manual assistance 60 min x 5/wk x 12 wk

Con2 = BWS treadmill-based training with stimulation 60 min x 5/wk x 12 wk

Con3 = OGT with stimulation with BWS 60 min x 5/wk x 12 wk

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Distance = 2-min walk test

• Leg strength = LEMS

• Timing: 0, 12 wk

Hornby 2005

RCT

n = 35

Time since injury (months) < 6 (14–180 days)

ASIA scale = B, C, D

Level of injury = Above

T10 (UMN)

Exp = RAGT 30 min x 3/wk x 8 wk

Con1 = BWS treadmill-based training with manual assistance 30 min x 3/wk x 8 wk

Con2 = OGT with BWS 30 min x 3/wk x 8 wk

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Distance = 6-min walk test

• Functional level = WISCI II, FIM-L

• Leg strength = LEMS

• Spasticity = MAS

• Balance = TUG

• Timing: 0, 8 wk

Labruyere 2014

RCT

Cross-over

n = 9

Time since injury (months) > 12

ASIA scale = C, D

Level of injury = C4 -T11 (UMN)

Exp = RAGT 45 min x 4/wk x 4 wk

Con = Strength 45 min x 4/wk x 4 wk

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Functional level = WISCI II

• Leg strength = LEMS

• Pain = VAS

• Balance = BBS

• Timing: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 wk

Niu 2014

RCT

n = 40

Time since injury (yrs) = Exp 8.9±9.9, Con 7.5±5.5

ASIA scale = B, C, D

Level of injury = above T10 (UMN)

Exp = RAGT 60 min x 3/wk x 4 wk

Con = no intervention

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Distance = 6-min walk test

• Balance = TUG

• Timing: 0, 1, 2, 4 wk

Shin 2014

RCT

n = 60

Time since injury (months) < 6

ASIA scale = D

Level of injury = UMN

Exp = RAGT 40 min x 3/wk x 4 wk

Con = OGT 30 min x 3/wk x 4 wk

Both = Usual PT 30 min x 2/wk x 4 wk

• Functional level = WISCI II, SCIM3, AMI

• Leg strength = LEMS

• Timing: 0, 4 wk

Tang 2014

RCT

n = 30

Time since injury (months) = 6.3

ASIA scale = D

Level of injury = T8 to L3 (UMN+LMN)

Exp = RAGT 40 min

Con = Bike 40 min

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Agility = probe reaction time

• Timing: before and after the intervention

Varoqui 2014

RCT

n = 30

Time since injury (yrs) = Exp 11.80±2.54, Con 8.09±1.89

ASIA scale = C, D

Level of injury = above T10 (UMN)

Exp = RAGT 60 min x 3/wk x 4 wk

Con = no intervention

• Speed = 10-m walk test

• Distance = 6-min walk test

• Balance = TUG

• Timing: 0, 4 wk

  1. Exp experimental group, Con control group, RAGT robotic-assisted gait training, OGT over-ground training), Strength, BWS body weight-supported gait training, WISCI walking index for spinal cord injury, LEMS lower extremities motor scale, FIM-L Functional Independence Measure – Lokomotion, MAS modified Ashworth scale, VAS visual analog scale, TUG timed up and go, AMI ambulatory motor index